What is the best rated breast pump on the market today? This is a question many moms ask all across the internet. With so many brands and pumps to choose from, how do you know you have made the best choice?
One piece of advice I always give moms when they ask me this question is to be sure they are buying the RIGHT pump, not necessarily the BEST pump. That might sound confusing but trust me, it will save you a lot of frustration.
In this article, I will discuss how to choose the best breast pump for you and your situation.
If you would like to read my review of top-rated pumps, click here to see my Breast Pump Review page.
Types of Pumps to Choose From:
It is important to know the various types of breast pumps that you can choose from. How often and where you plan on using your pump will make a difference in the type of pump you should consider.
Here are the types of pumps you will commonly see on the market:
Double Electric Pumps (My Recommendation)
A double electric pump is exactly what it sounds like – it is an electric pump that allows you to pump both breasts at the same time (double). Most can be used as a single pump as well which is helpful in cases where you only need to pump one side.
This pump is best for moms who will be pumping often (working, exclusively pumping, etc). It is a quick and easy way to pump and by far the most efficient.
Single Electric Pumps
A Single Electric pump is a pump that only pumps one breast at a time. These tend to be cheaper than a double electric pump for obvious reasons.
A single pump is good for moms who want to pump occasionally and need a slightly cheaper pump but still want an electric pump.
I do not recommend a single electric pump for moms who will be pumping both breasts multiple times per day. It will take forever.
Manual Pumps
A Manual Pump is a pump that has a lever that you manually squeeze to create suction to express milk. It is 100% powered by you, hence the name.
Manual Pumps are good for moms who will be pumping rarely or as a backup to have on hand in case something happens to your electric pump. They are extremely cheap and easy to use. I would not recommend a manual pump to any moms who plan to pump more than a few times a week.
While a manual pump has some positives (cheap, allows you to have 100% control of the speed and suction strength), it is not the most efficient way to pump and can get tiring. An electric pump is by far a better choice for any mom who wants to pump.
Choosing the Right Breast Pump for You
Now that you are familiar with the types of breast pumps, you need to decide a few things before picking a pump:
- How often will you be pumping?
- Where will you be pumping? Do you need a portable pump?
- Are you suffering from low milk supply or need to pump exclusively?
- What is your budget?
The answers to these questions will help you narrow down your options. Not all double electric pumps are made equal so even if you plan to get one of those, you will want to ask yourself these questions.
Here are a few examples to show you how I would pick for each scenario:
Example 1:
- How often will you be pumping? A: Occasionally.
- Where will you be pumping? Do you need a portable pump? A: At home. No portable pump needed.
- Are you suffering from low milk supply or need to pump exclusively? A: Low milk Supply and need a quality pump.
- What is your budget? A: On a Budget. Can’t afford the most expensive pump.
For this mom, I would recommend: Spectra S2 Breast Pump
The Spectra S2 is a Hospital Grade, double electric pump. The best for low supply. It does not have a battery pack so it is not portable. It is extremely affordable. Perfect for a mom on a budget who doesn’t want to sacrifice quality! This pump is one of the best on the market.
Example 2:
- How often will you be pumping?A: Daily.
- Where will you be pumping? Do you need a portable pump? A: Work, need a portable pump
- Are you suffering from low milk supply or need to pump exclusively? A: No low supply.
- What is your budget? A: Modest budget.
For this mom, I would recommend: Spectra S1 or Medela Pump in Style
Both the S1 and Pump in Style are strong pumps, perfect for a mom who needs to keep her supply up when working. They are both portable and have battery power as an option. They are not the most expensive pumps but not the cheapest either.
In each of the above examples, the moms could have chosen from a number of electric pumps. For a mom who has a low milk supply or will be pumping a lot, not all electric pumps will work for her.
For example, the Ameda Purely Yours is a solid pump by most standards but I would not recommend it for a mom with low supply or who pumps a lot. The reason? The suction is lower than other top-rated pumps. There are stronger pumps on the market like the Spectra pumps.
No matter what pump you decide on, make sure it fits your situation and needs. You don’t want to be in a situation where you spend money on a pump you need to replace later. Trust me, I come across moms in that situation daily and it’s a costly mistake.
Remember, buying a breast pump is not the time to go cheap just because you think you will get by. Getting the wrong pump can greatly impact your milk supply and cause an enormous amount of stress. So choose wisely!
Click here to read my reviews on various breast pumps and find out which is my favorite!
Need a pump suggestion? Confused about what fits your situation best? Leave me a comment or question below and let me help you choose!
Happy Pumping!
Kelsey says
Hi! I found this blog and it is so helpful! Not sure if you’re still responding to comments on here but wanted to get your opinion. I’m a first time mom at almost 38 weeks. I will be working full time after 12 week maternity leave so I need a pump that is portable. I plan to continue breastfeeding at the breast while home but will need to definitely pump at work. I’ve been considering the Spectra S1 but my insurance does not cover – it would be $135 out of pocket which isn’t terrible but my insurance does cover several other pumps 100% or close to it
so I was curious what your thoughts might be.
1. Motif Duo
2. Motif Luna (would only be $30)
3. Lansinoh Signature Pro double
4. Lansinoh smartpump 2.0
5. Zomee Z2
6. Ameda Mya Joy
7. Medela Pump in style
8. Evenflow Advanced
9. Spectra S2 (only $30)
Kelsey says
Hi! I found this blog and it is so helpful! Not sure if you’re still responding to comments on here but wanted to get your opinion. I’m a first time mom at almost 38 weeks. I will be working full time after 12 week maternity leave. I think I will I prefer a pump that is portable. I plan to continue breastfeeding at the breast while home but will need to definitely pump at work. I’ve been considering the Spectra S1 but my insurance does not cover – it would be $135 out of pocket which isn’t terrible but my insurance does cover several other pumps 100% or close to it
so I was curious what your thoughts might be.
1. Motif Duo
2. Motif Luna (would only be $30)
3. Lansinoh Signature Pro double
4. Lansinoh smartpump 2.0
5. Zomee Z2
6. Ameda Mya Joy
7. Medela Pump in style
8. Evenflow Advanced
9. Spectra S2 (only $30)
Thanks so much!
Kelsey
Shir says
Hi! I’m an exclusive pumper. I currently have and use the Spectra S2 and require the highest cycle and suction to get the most milk out – so I’m looking for something STRONG, hospital grade, and portable is a plus. I have low supply due to hypoplasia (11-12 oz per day) and am trying to upregulate as I am still within the first 12 weeks. This is what’s covered – what do you think? Already bought a Baby Buddha out of pocket and that’s on the way.
-Unimom Opera
-Unimom Zomee Z2
-Medela Advanced Starte
-Ameda Mya Joy
-Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0
-Ardo Calypso
-Freemie Independence
-Spectra S9
-Or I can get a second Spectra S2, lol
Shir Oring says
Hi! I currently have and use the Spectra S2 and require the highest level of suction to get any milk out – so I’m looking for something STRONG, and portable is a plus. I have low supply due to hypoplasia (11-12 oz per day) and am trying to upregulate as I am still within the first 12 weeks. This is what’s covered – what do you think? Already bought a Baby Buddha out of pocket and that’s on the way.
-Unimom Opera
-Unimom Zomee Z2
-Medela Advanced Starte
-Ameda Mya Joy
-Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0
-Ardo Calypso
-Freemie Independence
-Spectra S9
-Or I can get a second Spectra S2, lol
Natasha says
Hello, I am exclusively pumping and have a low supply. I would like a hands free pump that is reasonably priced and allows me to do chores around the house. Thanks!!
LL says
I currently have a Spectra s2 and am looking for a secondary pump. I am choosing between Spectra s9 and freemie independent ii (which I heard is newer). I have concerns with suction power for S9 but reading here sounds like the fit of freemie cups may not be great either. I have larger breasts DD. Love the idea of a cup that fits inside the bra though! I like that s9 has a display but I can live without it honestly. Insurance said s9 is more popular but I really like to idea of the freemie cups. They also said it could be because this freemie indep. ii is newer. They warned freemie used to have leaking problems and battery which could be mitigated by new version. I don’t want to buy the cups and then a different pump.
Jamie says
Hi! I’m expecting my first baby in September, I plan on breastfeeding and I’m hoping it all works out for me! I like the idea of pumping to make bottles and have occasional help with feedings or for when I go back to work, etc etc. My insurance told me they cover either the Medela Pump In Style advance starter set, or the Ameda Mya Joy double electric breast pump. I was wondering if you had any advice on which one I should go with? For a first time mama, I’m having a hard time deciding which would would be the best for me! Thank you for your time and feedback! 🙂
Jen says
Hi Heather! I have spent a LOT of time on your blog today. Thank you for all the research and great reviews!
I am a first-time mom due in about 8 weeks. I just received the list of pumps I can choose from my insurance and have been reading your reviews, but honestly they all seem good. Can I go wrong?
I hope to breastfeed and pump regularly, through the first year and possibly beyond. Right now I work from home but may seek a career change and need to pull long hours at the office. We also love to travel and will *hopefully* be able to in 2022, so portable is appealing, but I’m willing to need an A/C adapter if it means a better pump. Speed, comfort, and ease are most important – I’ve never done this before (!) so it’s hard to troubleshoot in advance!
From reading your reviews, I’ve shortlisted:
– Spectra S2
– Motif Luna (I can pay $30 to get the battery-operated option)
– Motif Duo
– Ameda Mya Joy Double electric
I was leaning toward the spectra or luna, but then I saw you highly praise ameda, which I haven’t seen on any other “best pump” lists.
Would love to hear what you recommend for a first-time mom like me 🙂
Thank you thank you!
lindsay says
I am a working mom with two boys and have one on the way. Due in about 11 weeks!! Frist pump i had was the Medela PISA and it was great! loved it. Second one I tried a different route just to see and got the spectra (the pink one). it like that one to. no issues. If i had to say, the medela i prob liked better, but really both were great. Now for my third, i get another pump through insurance and I really need something that I can use at work. I have my own office so Im okay to be plugged in as I usually chart while pumping anyway. But i need something that has good suction and a long life since I will be using it while at work (at min three times a day). I also pump in the AM (first thing) while feeding baby, but other than thay I usually dont have to pump at home, but may have to on occasion (every child is different). I was looking at the Medela pump in style max flow and the Ameda Mya. Ive read pros and cons of both but need anther opinion. My concern is having two crazy kiddos running around but then not having enough suction and getting enough milk out when i do have to pump
rena k harbeck says
Sorry if this comes twice I can’t remember if I actually posted or not the first time
36 weeks pregnant and need to get my pump from insurance. I had supply issues with the kiddo. I don’t necessarily care about how compact, I just want the one that will hopefully be best to get the most milk
I have a few options. Any feedback/advice would be amazing. TYIA
Medela PISA
Spectra 9plus
Spectra S2plus
Ameda Mya
Ardo Calypso
Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0 Deluxe
Freemie
Evenflo Advanced
Medline
rena k harbeck says
I am 36 weeks pregnant with my second. Struggled with my first (she’s 5 now) with a low supply. I was breastfeeding, pumping and supplementing. I am going to try to breastfeed this time but will need to pump as well bc I’m going back to work. I am so lost as to what to get
Julie says
Hi Heather,
Thank you for the informative website. I am a FTM and I have no idea what my supply or pumping needs will be. I plan on taking 16 weeks of maternity leave and going back to work full time. As of right now I am still working from home and don’t know if I will need to return to the office. I called my insurance and they cover 19 different pumps! I am happy but so overwhelmed. My options include: Ameda Hospital or Joy, Ardo Calypso, Evenflo Deluxe, Freemie hands free, Lanisonoh 2.0 or Signature Pro, Medela PIS, Spectra 1, 2 or 9, Unimom minut, zombee double, Medline and Motif Luna. (The rest have an upgrade option that is out of my budget). Do I go with a safe pick like Spectra or Motif or do I go with something a little more portable in case I need to use it on the go like Ameda or Ardo? Thanks in advance!
Ashlee says
This has been the most helpful site so far! I am expecting in a few weeks, and not sure which pump to get. I already have the Spectra S2 from my first child (2.5 years old) and figure I can still use it this time. My insurance will cover a second pump, so I’d like to get something else and am hoping you can help.
With the spectra, I was able to pump a lot of milk in the first few months but eventually stopped responding and only responded to hand expression and nursing. I know the Spectra has some of the best reviews, but would like something with strong suction that mimics the natural suction of the baby. I also would like something more portable as we plan to travel by RV this summer and may not always have easy access to electricity. I also want a closed system. My insurance covers the following pumps:
Ameda Mya Hospital Strength; Ameda Mya Joy; Ardo Calypso Essentials; Evenflo Deluxe Advanced; Freemie Independence; Lansinoh Smartpump 2.0; Medela Pump in Style; Unimom Minuet; and the Zomee.
Any suggestions would be really appreciated!
Heather Grace says
Hi Ashlee!
I am so glad you have found this site so helpful! Huge congrats on your pregnancy!
So for the pumps you listed, I have tried a few of them. The Ardo Calypso is great and I think you will find it to be a good portable pump. You can read my full review, here. The downside is that it is battery-powered and not a built-in rechargeable battery. Something to keep in mind when you are searching for a good portable pump. You just need to be sure to keep batteries on hand.
The Ameda Mya has a built-in rechargeable battery and is very portable. I generally have come to LOVE Ameda pumps. I own several. I have not tested the Mya, however (it’s on my list). But I have done extensive research on it and the review are mostly positive.
I think something to keep in mind is the goals you have in pumping. If you plan to breastfeed your baby almost exclusively and use your pump to boost your milk supply or be able to give an occasional bottle, then any pump (for the most part) will do perfectly. Since you have a specific need for a portable and convenient pump while traveling, you should find one with features that will fit that lifestyle. The Mya is a great choice for that. If you needed to exclusively pump, I would recommend you invest in a strong, portable pump that will maintain your milk supply and empty your breast fast and efficiently. The Spectra S1, Medela Freestyle, Medela Sonata, Motif Luna, Milk Genie, etc are all pumps to look into if you want to spend money outside what your insurance provides. They may give you money toward the purchase of a pump as an option as well, so ask about that.
But the Mya, Pump in Style, Ardo Calypso would be my picks from this list. The Unimom Minuet has caught my eye as well but I have not tried it so I can’t give a positive review of it. I want to love it but I won’t recommend something I haven’t tried but worth looking into! I hope this helps!
Sam Stow says
Hi,
I am exclusively pumping and have an ok supply. I currently use the Ardo Calypso but find I have to use hands on techniques for it to be effective. I also feel as though it doesn’t “empty” the Breast properly and have had blocked ducts and mastitis since using it. I also feel the suction is quite weak – before exclusively pumping I used the cheap Bella Baby and it was so much stronger. What would you recommend? I’m considering Spectra 1/2 or Medela but want some advice before investing in yet another pump!
Thanks
Sam x
Heather Grace says
Hi Sam,
Sometimes a certain pump just doesn’t work for a mom. I have found this happens from time to time. I love the Spectra pumps. If you need a battery pack for your pump, then the Spectra S1 is the way to go. The S2 only works when plugged into a power source.
As for Medela, there are a lot of models to chose from. Both the Freestyle and Sonata are amazing and great for working moms.
I would say that you will have similar success with any of those pumps. They have a lot of the same features (though look quite different) and have similar suction strength.
Katherine A Ripullone says
Hi,
I am expecting my first baby early next year. I plan on breast feeding — and the baby willl be going into daycare at 6 months (I’m a doctor). For my home pump I was thinking the Spectra S1 (good all around pump) – but am a bit stumped for a pump for work. Light, efficient, ideally double (but open to single), with good battery?
Any help, much appreciated!
Heather Grace says
Hi! Congrats on your pregnancy! If you need something super compact, I suggest you look at a few pumps-
Spectra 9
Ameda Mya
Medela Freestyle
Motif Duo
Milk Genie
Elvie
You will find each has its pros and cons. I love the Medela Freestyle. The Milk Genie and Motif Duo are very similar and both great. The Elvie is a wearable pump that has amazing reviews. The Spectra 9 will be compatible with the parts you have for the S1 and is a great portable pump. Let me know if you have any questions about any of these pumps!
Johanna says
Hello!
I’m a first time mom and my son is 5 weeks old. He has had trouble latching since day 1 so I heavily rely on pumping to get him fed with breastmilk. We rented a Medela Symphony from the hospital and I’ve found it to be great, but my insurance will cover a breast pump and so I’m wondering if it’s worth getting something else since it’s free or heavily discounted and then we can stop the rental.
A few things to note:
– My supply is mediocre. I am currently pumping about 75% of what my son needs on a daily basis – we supplement with formula.
– I’m on maternity leave until December and likely will be working from home after that with COVID so portability isn’t a priority, though we may take a road trip or plane trip, so it’d be nice if it wasn’t impossible to bring it with me
– I was really hoping to find a Medela brand pump where I can use the same replacement parts I have for the Symphony but it seems that’s not the case – do you know for sure?
Lastly, I have a Spectra S1 that a friend gave me – she ended up not using it but I’d need to buy some spare parts and such to get going using it regularly. I welcome any advice on which pump can help me continue to get the quantity (or even help improve it) but possibly allow me to get rid of the rental and leverage my insurance benefits.
Thanks,
Johanna
Heather Grace says
Hi Johanna!
First, huge congrats on your baby!
Have you worked with a lactation consultant to address your supply issues? It sounds like your body hasn’t quite caught up after those first few weeks which can be typical. I would suggest working with one asap to get a good plan in place to help you get your supply up.
As for your questions:
Unfortunately, the Medela Symphony parts are not compatible with other Medela single user pumps. Though any pump you buy will come with the parts needed and Medela parts are available just about anywhere if you want to purchase an extra set.
I would start by calling your insurance to see which pumps they will cover for you. Most have a shortlist of approved pumps or will reimburse you up to a specific amount. That’s a good place to start.
The Spectra S1 is a great pump and will work fine in your situation. It’s a strong pump, portable, easy to use, and has a lot of great features. I highly recommend it. Your insurance may cover a Spectra pump if you want to have a backup. You can also inquire if they will help toward the cost of the rental. Often with a prescription from your doctor, they will. So you can ask that as well.
I hope this helps!
Yuliya says
Hi,
I just had my fourth baby, and I’m trying to decide which breast pump to pick from the ones offerred by my insurance. I’m a stay-at-home mom with flexible part-time work, and I intend to use the pump about once a week to be able to leave the baby with someone while I see clients, take care of errands, go to a doctor’s appointment, etc.
My insurance offers the following choices:
– Medela Pump-in-Style Advanced starter set
– Ameda Finesse starter set
– ARDO Calypso Essentials
– Zomee Double Electric breast pump
I’ve used Ameda Purely Yours with my first two babies a long time ago and was fairly satisfield with it, although I’m not sure if it provided sufficient suction. Back then, I chose it over Medela due Ameda having a closed system. My breastfeeding is well-established, and I have no issues with supply, soreness, etc. My breasts are on the smaller side (size B when not pregnant or nursing). My only concern is finding a pump that will be as efficient as a baby at getting the milk out.
My ideal pump would have the following features:
– durable, with quality parts
– closed system
– hospital-strength (3 of the pumps – Ameda, ARDO and Zomee claim to be “hospital strength”)
– mimic baby’s sucking & efficiently extract milk
– let-down & expression settings or some kind of memory settings
– customizable settings for speed & suction
– portability (not too heavy, rechargeable batteries)
– not too loud
I realize that none of these pumps has all these features, and I wish that my insurance covered one of the Spectra pumps (as it seems to be a nearly perfect fit). However, all I have is a choice of these four pumps, and I wanted to hear your opinion on which one would be the best fit for me.
Thank you so much!
Heather Grace says
Hi! Congratulations on your 4th baby. I’m a mom of 4 so I can so relate to the season of life you are in!
So the 3 pumps you listed are actually all very similar feature-wise. You made a good list of your “wants” in a pump so I will help you focus on those:
1. Durable, with quality parts – Ameda and Ardo are very reputable companies with excellent products both would be good choices as far as quality. I have not heard good things in terms of quality on the Zomee pump. Reviews of it seem to reflect that.
2. Closed system – They are all closed system.
3. Hospital-strength – They are all “hospital strength.” You can read this article to further explain that definition.
4. Mimic baby’s sucking & efficiently extract milk – The Ameda Finesse, in my opinion, felt the most natural of these pumps.
5. Let-down & expression settings or some kind of memory settings – Unfortunately, none of these pumps features a programable memory mode or an automatic “let down” button. The Ameda is a dial control and the Ardo and Zomee have digital screens.
6. Customizable settings for speed & suction – You can control the speed and suction separately with all 3 but again it is manual control, not a memory that you program.
7. Portability (not too heavy, rechargeable batteries) – All are very portable in that they are small, light and easy to carry. None of them have a built-in rechargeable battery. They all take disposable batteries so that is something to consider if you plan to pump away from a power source often.
8. Not too loud – The Ardo is my pick for the quietest pump of the 3. None of them are loud but the Ardo is definitely whisper-quiet!
With what you described, I think the Ameda Finesse might be a good pick for you. Especially if you still have some leftover bottles and accessories from using the Purely Yours model since the parts are interchangeable. The Ardo would be a close second and is a great pump. I would stick to either one of those. I hope this helps!
Corrine Beeck says
I am looking at a new pump. I have the spectra s2 (which I’ll still be using at home) and used it with my son where I had low supply issues and exclusively pumped. It worked well for me minus not being portable.
My son will be 2 in July and I’m due in June so I’m looking for portable that can help prevent low supply this time around.
My insurance will cover Medela Pisa, Spectra S9, Ameda Mya and Finesse, Lansinoh smart pump and signature pro, freemie independence, and Ardo Calypso.
My concerns are…
-Strength of the pump due to my low supply
-Portability
-Quality
Portability being #1 because I travel a lot to see family and my son has multiple doctors appointments that we have to travel for as well as my own. I tend to be out of my house for 8 hours a day at least once a week for 1 reason or another and not always able to get to a power source to pump. Plus adding in a toddler to the mix with a newborn will be interesting in itself.
Heather Grace says
Hi Corrine,
Congrats on baby #2!
With Travel in mind, I recommend you check out the Ameda Mya and Spectra 9. Of the pumps you listed they are the two favorites of mine that have a rechargeable built-in battery. The Spectra 9 doesn’t have as many options as the Spectra 2 in terms of cycle memory but it is very compact and would be perfect for traveling. You would be able to use the spectra bottles you already have with it as well. You can read more about the Spectra 9, here.You can read more about the Spectra 9, here.
The Ameda Mya is a newer pump but has great reviews. It would be a great choice as well. You can read about the Ameda Mya’s features, here.You can read about the Ameda Mya’s features, here.
I hope this helps!
Rebecca Sailors says
Hello! I’m trying to decide on a portable pump to carry with me to work. I have an S2 that I will use at home from my last breastfeeding journey. My insurance will only cover the Motif duo. But I have an FSA/HSA so I don’t mind having to buy a different one outright. I’m looking more at the Ameda mya, Medela Sonata, and the Spectra 9.
Rebecca Sailors says
I misspoke, my insurance will only fully cover the Motif Duo.
Heather Grace says
Hi Rebecca!
I really like the Motif Duo and think it’s a great pump, especially if you need something on the go. That said, the pumps you listed really can fit into two groups.
First, you have the Motif Duo, Spectra 9 and the Ameda Mya. They are all similar in size, features, strength and battery life. I personally, would stick to the Motif Duo if your insurance will cover it. I don’t find these pumps to be that much different. The Mya might be slightly superior of the 3, but just slightly…
Then, you have the Medela Sonata and the Spectra S2. They are similar in size but have some distinct differences such as portability- as you know, the S2 doesn’t have a battery option and needs to be plugged into the wall outlet. The Sonata has a built-in rechargeable battery. The Sonata also has more options and features. The MyMedela App is one of my favorite things about the Sonata and is a great pump for moms who work or are on the go.
If you need something portable, the Motif Duo is a great option and you will have no issue using it fulltime. I personally wouldn’t shell out more money unless you tried the Duo and just didn’t find it works for you.
If you want a pump that performs better and longer off a battery, has more control options and features but is still lightweight and portable, then I would go with the Sonata. It’s a great pump and will not disappoint!
I hope this helps!
sophie london says
I’m trying to decide between the Ameda Mya & the Freemie Independence-both options are the most compact and portable offered by my health insurance. The Ameda Mya reviews are great, the only benefit I see of the Freemie is the more discreet cups which Do seem like a plus when walking around/driving and pumping, although they sound a little harder to clean… I will primarily be pumping once I have to return to work and leave my baby for the day. I’ve also read about some women using the Ameda pump with the Freemie cups but they don’t mention why they prefer the Ameda pump….THANK YOU!!!
Heather Grace says
Hi Sophie!
I have not used the Freemie Independence but I have used the Freemie cups with other pumps. From what I have gathered, you either love the Freemie cups or strongly dislike them. I was on the side of disliking them. They didn’t work for me. I don’t have any information to back this up and it’s purely anecdotal but I believe the Freemie cups aren’t great for larger breasts. I could not get a proper fit in any bra I tried (I have large breasts). They never felt snug enough and it took forever to pump anything. I hear this time and time again from moms with large breasts so that leads me to believe this is a common problem.
I am a huge fan of the Ameda Mya and think its an amazing pump.
I personally prefer to pump with a good pumping bra as the Freemie isn’t cordless so to me it’s no different than wearing a pumping bra. This is purely my experience. It is unfortunate that you can’t try these things out before buying them (and you can’t return a pump in most cases). I would do lots of research on the Freemie before buying and honestly look at breast size as a factor. I hope this helps!
Jessica Riley says
Hi, your blog Is very helpful!! I’m looking at the ameda mya , the freemie independence spectra 9 and spectra s2 as they are covered by the insurance. I will mostly be pumping for at work as long as this baby latches and wants to nurse. My first wanted nothing to do with any of it. That was eight years ago so I dont know what my production will be, but it was not great last time to the point I did not make it more than 4 months and I formula supplemented him. I dont think my pump was great last time and I think I was under educated about how to have a better supply. That said.. My question is what pump is going to be more efficent. I like the fact that the freemie has the cups but the ameda seems like its may have a better pump. It will more than likely be my only pump so I want to choose one that I can use several times a day and will be reliable .. will the mya hook up with the freemie cups so I have both options. Or should I just go with the bulk of the s2. . Would it be better to get a portable from the insurance for work and try to save for a home pump in case the portable is not efficent enough ???
Heather Grace says
Hi Jessica,
Congrats on your baby!
The Freemie cups should work with the Ameda. I have not personally tried them with the Mya, however, Ameda parts are typically interchangeable from pump to pump (Thank you, Ameda!!) so it shouldn’t be any fancy new parts.
If milk supply is something you are concerned about, the Spectra S2 is a fantastic pump. It would be your best bet from the list you posted. If you want something more portable, the Spectra S9 and Mya for good choices. Strength-wise, the S2 is the one I would go with, however!
Jill says
Hi!
I’m a first time mom looking to see which pump to get. I’m hoping to exclusively breast feed and not sure how my milk supply/let down will be in the beginning.
I’ve heard Spectra S2 and Ameda Mya are good pumps – which do you recommend for a first time mom?
Thank you !
Heather Grace says
Hi Jill,
Congratulations on your first baby!
Rest assured that the vast majority of moms have a perfectly normal/healthy milk supply. Many supply issues come from misinformation (outside of health reasons for mom and baby) and can be corrected with proper technique. With that said, both the S2 and the Mya are said to be great pumps.
I love, love the Spectra S2 and think it is an amazing choice.
I have not yet personally used the Ameda Mya, though it is on my list to try. From the feedback I have gotten directly from moms who have used it, they seem to like it. It reminds more of the Spectra 9 than the S2.
I think one of the biggest differences (outside of their sizes- the Mya being more compact), is the fact that the Mya has a built-in rechargeable battery. The S2 can only be used when plugged into the wall. So if having something more portable is important to you, then the Mya is a good choice. Their product listings show a similar pump strength so it’s hard for me to say which yields more milk without testing it. Let me know if you have any other questions! I hope this helps!
vkrystala says
Hi,
I like all of the different pumps you have covered. I am pregnant with number 2, and am looking for a new breast pump. I used the medala in style with my first baby, plus a hand pump, and a haaka hand pump. You know variety is the spice of life. My medala worked great for me, but it was SO loud. I did not have a supply issue and had a very strong letdown. This time I think I want a closed system breast pump. Looking at having the option for portability as well. It’s been a year and a half since I’ve used my medala and I’m not sure I want to use it with #2 since it’s an open system. We will have a separate room set up for pumping at work. I have a lot more options this time with insurance. I have large breasts, and used the 24mm or 27mm flanges. Through my insurance I can receive the:
-Medala in style
-either of the spectras (9 or s2)
– ameda maya
-ardo clypso
-lasinoh (double or deluxe double)
-fremie
I am down to debating between the Spectra 2 and the Ardo Calypso. I would love your input on these 2 or if you would suggest a different one on the list o can receive from my insurance. I do not believe the fremie or the lansinoh options will meet my needs. Thanks!
Heather Grace says
Hi!
You have some great options. Since you have no history with supply issues and the Medela Pump in Style worked great last time, both the S2 and the Calypso will work just fine in terms of strength and milk pumped.
So there are a few differences:
1) Battery – The S2 does not have an option to run off batteries. It needs to be plugged into an outlet to work. That may or may not be a deal-breaker for you. The Calypso runs off disposable batteries and can work plugged in.
2) Cycle Modes – The Calypso does not feature a letdown mode. It is digital but you need to manually move the suction and speed to mimic a letdown mode. The S2 has all that built into it.
3) Size – The Calypso is more compact and is lighter.
4) Noise – Both are quiet pumps!
I like the S2 overall better than the Calypso because of the cycle features. But both are great pumps! I think this will come down to how often you need to pump without access to a power source and if you need something more compact while on the go!
Vkrystala says
Thank you for the response. I will have to think a bit more on the 2. The power shouldn’t be an issue, but portability may play a factor. I just hadn’t heard too much about the Calypso until I saw it on my insurance list. I did read your review as well. Thanks!
Heather Grace says
The Calypso isn’t talked about all that much here in the US. It is a good pump and if you need something lighter, it would be a good choice. It is tough to choose! Let me know if you have any other questions!
Rachel says
Curious to get an opinion on the Ameda Mya. I am in a situation where I’m not sure what my pumping needs will be (baby is due September 12 and I’m a first time mom), so just trying to keep an open door on all this and pick the best option! I like the fact that the Ameda Mya is portable, but want to make sure it will be a good pump. I think it would be best to have a battery option in the event an outlet isn’t available, so I’ve been looking at the Ameda Mya, Spectra S1 and the Lanisoh. Any opinions on which way to go will be helpful! And if there is a better pump option I should be considering but did not list, please let me know!
Heather Grace says
Hi Rachel!
The Ameda Mya has been getting great reviews from moms. It seems like it was Ameda’s answer for the Medela Freestyle and other handheld pumps. Historically, Ameda pumps take disposable batteries so this was a nice change for them to include a built-in rechargeable one.
The Lanisoh is not my personal favorite. I think there are better pumps out there. The Spectra S1 is one of my favorites, however, and I think it’s a great choice. I still believe the S1 is slightly better than the Mya but you need to weigh the difference to choose between them.
Size is a big difference. While the S1 is light, it is not small. You will need a pump bag for it. The Mya could, in theory, fit into your purse (assuming you can get all the attachments and accessories you need in there with it). It is much smaller.
The Mya boasts that it will last 2 hours at full strength. I think the S1 might be closer to 4. I don’t seem to notice a reduction in strength until them. So if it being portable is really important to you, then I would go with the Spectra S1.
I hope this helps!
Christy says
I would LOVE to hear your pick for me!
I am a teacher, so will definitely be pumping daily at work. Price is not a factor as my insurance is fully paying for the pump. I have not had a problem with low milk supply in the past, BUT it has been 15 years (I know!), I’m older now (42), AND I do recall having a hard time pumping with my last kiddo. It took FOREVER and got very little output. I’m hoping pumps have come a long way in the last 15 years!
Heather Grace says
Hi Christy! Pumps have come a very long way in just the last few years so you will be pleasantly surprised, trust me! Definitely take a look at the Spectra S1 or the Medela Freestyle! Both have a built-in rechargeable battery and would be perfect for pumping in the classroom. The Spectra is going to be a little more gentle and has some great pump strength. It is covered by some insurance companies so that makes it friendly from that standpoint.
The Freestyle is not usually covered by insurance directly but you might be able to get an allowance toward it. It is much smaller than the Spectra and would be a great choice if you need something more compact. It is one of my favorites among the handheld pumps.
Huge congrats on your pregnancy!
Mariam Lazar says
Hello! I am a FTM & came across your blog by reading some breast pump reviews. I am completely lost & new when it comes to breast pumping! I am exclusively breast feeding but would like to build up a stash for my husband for nighttime feddings, when I’m not home or unable to breast feed. I am also a stay at home mom. Im looking for a pump thats
-good for large breasts
-daily pumping but possibly only 1-2 times a day. I am trying to exclusively breastfeed for another month or two to build up a freezer stash.
– closed system (don’t want to stress about bacteria in open systems)
– Something comfortable and not painful! Breastfeeding was very painful on one side its gotten a lot better but im just nervous about th
e pain. i want something that feels gentle & won’t give me sore nipples but still effective
– double electric
-Something easy to use and learn quick and understand
– Im going through my ins and they offer the pumps below but if that pump does not work im looking into buying one and I would have no budget
– Stationary or portable is good. I will most likely be pumping at home most of the time but portable would be nice just in case.
The options i have through my ins are
*Lansinoh Signature pro
* Ameda Finesse with tote
*Medela Advanced personal Double breast pump starter kit
*Medela pump in style advanced starter kit (I know this is an open system but if it has most of what i want i will look into getting this one)
I was looking into the spectra 1 but ins doesnt cover it but was thinking if one of the above dont work i would just buy it
Thank you for your help, your blog is awesome for FTM !
Heather Grace says
Hi Mariam!
Thank you for your sweet comment about the blog! I am glad you have found it useful!
For what you are describing, the Ameda Finesse would be a good pump for you. I actually found it very comfortable to use. In my review of it, I mentioned pumping through a bout of thrush which makes breastfeeding extremely painful. The Finesse was very gentle despite me being terrified! It is also portable and small but can still be used plugged in while at home. It’s a great pump!
The fact your insurance covers it is a huge plus in my book!
I would recommend you give that a try!
The Spectra S1 is a favorite of mine and would check all the boxes you mentioned as well but I think the Finesse would work just fine for what you need! I hope this helps!
Mariam Lazar says
I read your great review on it and just wanted to make sure you wouldn’t recommend any of the others! Thank you so much for your help, I ordered it and I’m excited to try it. Im so happy to have found this blog to learn and look back on for any question/tips/help Im sure I’m going to need lol!
Thank you again 🙂
Heather Grace says
Great! I do think you will love it. Let me know if you have any other questions!
Rohini Ghosh says
Hi I am exclusive pumping as I have to relactate due to poor health of my baby and not responding well to formulae. I gave started getting milk but I have to increase my supply and pump 8 to 12 times a day. Appreciate your advise.
Heather Grace says
Hi Rohini,
I am so sorry your baby isn’t well! Exclusive pumping isn’t always easy but it certainly is possible! I have a complete guide for exclusive pumping that will give you some good tips- you can click here to read that.
I also have 2 articles that might help in regard to increasing your milk supply (click on the link to read):
20 Ways to Increase your Supply
Not Pumping Enough Milk
That will give you some additional tricks to get that supply up.
In regards to a pump for exclusively pumping for your situation, I don’t always suggest a hospital grade pump but in your case, it might help a lot. I would start by asking your insurance company first if they will cover the cost of a rental. Your doctor might need to prescribe it but with a sick infant, they might be willing to.
If that is not an option, the next best thing would be to look at investing in a very strong pump. My top choices for someone with low milk supply are:
1) Spectra S1
2) Medela Sonata
3) Ameda Finesse
It’s possible your insurance might cover one of those. If not, I would jump over to Amazon and buy the Spectra S1. It will be perfect for what you need and give you the strength to maximize every pumping session.
I hope this helps and please feel free to reach out with any additional questions!
Carolyn says
Hello! First time mom and I love your blog. I would like a hospital grade pump closed system. I will be pumping both at work and home and occasional travel but I anticipate having access to outlets whenever I am pumping (hopefully). I wish I could get the Spectra S1 but it was not listed as covered by my insurance. I had only heard of the Spectra and Medela when first researching so I was leaning on the Spectra S2 but was secretly wishing for a little more portability, but know that the S9 is not good to use as your only pump. I was hoping you would have advice on if any of these other options covered by my insurance would be a better fit than the S2.
Medela Pump in Style Advanced Starter Set
Spectra 9Plus
Spectra S2Plus
Ameda Mya
Ardo Calypso Essentials
Tomy Quiet Expressions Plus Double
Lansinoh Signature Pro Double
Lansinoh Smartpump Double
Freemie Independence Mobile
Evenflo Advanced Double
Thank you so much!
Heather Grace says
Great question! I do love the Spectra S2 (as a side note, if you really wanted a portable option, you could spend about $50 to make the S2 portable- here’s an article on how- click here) but for a small, portable, and strong pump, I think the best on your list is the Ameda Mya. I have not written a review on it yet but I have heard nothing but great things from moms who are using it (it’s on my list!)! It has all the things you mentioned that you want in a pump. I have been very impressed. You can read more about it and the features, here. I hope this helps!
Karina Caldwell says
Hi Heather!
Thank you so much for creating this website and resource for new moms and not so new moms! I have found your research and reviews SO helpful! I am a second time mommy, in my 37th week. With my first, I had low milk supply due to thyroid issues, I believe. I wasn’t able to increase milk supply with teas or herbs because most of them are not recommended to be used when taking a synthroid. In any case, I currently have a Medela Pump in Style pump and am curious if you would recommend anything else? I am hoping for increased milk supply this time around, but am not sure that will happen. I will be pumping to increase supply, build some supply for going back to work and pumping at work at least once a week. I am thinking about a pump that I would just keep at home because I can take my medela to work. I had to supplement with formula with my last little one and would love to not have to do that this time around. Any suggestions would be GREATLY appreciated.
Thank you so much!!
Heather Grace says
Hi! Congrats on your baby!
Personally, I would check out the Spectra pumps. It sounds like you need a slightly stronger pump and the Spectra S1 will give you that. I also found them incredibly comfortable to use which helps to be able to pump for a full 20 minutes.
If you haven’t checked with your insurance, you might want to see what they cover. Quite a few are covering the Spectra pumps. If you aren’t sure how to start that process, you can use a free service like Aeroflow Breastpumps (I’ve used them and it’s amazing) and they will call your insurance and get you your pump. They can review the pump features with you as well. Worth a call!
But even if you needed to purchase the Spectra, they aren’t the most expensive pumps.
Another amazing pump options for working moms, moms who have low milk supply, and moms who want to build a freezer stash is the Medela Sonata. It features their hospital grade pump the Symphony’s expression technology and is amazing. It also connects via Bluetooth to their MyMedela app which allows you to track your pumping sessions and milk that you expressed (as well as baby feedings, sleep, etc). Definitely worth checking out!
I hope this helps!
Mallorie says
Hi Heather,
I love your website and just wanted to say thanks for helping us all out on this pumping journey! I am 36 weeks pregnant with my second baby, so I don’t know exactly what my breastfeeding/pumping journey will look like this time around, but after my first baby (currently 17 months and will be 18 months when baby #2 arrives) I exclusively pumped (with formula supplementation here and there due to first time mom fears of not being able to meet feeding demand) for 9 months (due to tongue and lip tie) and would have loved to have made it to a year, but was just exhausted and honestly burnt out from pumping, so this time around I am trying to do my research and find the most appropriate pump for our lifestyle. The first time around I used the Medela In Style with the Freemie cups so I could pump hand free. This time around I would continue to be able to pump hands free, as I will return to work after 8-10 weeks and will also have a toddler running around, pump on the go as needed, and ensure that I am able to maintain my supply to the one year mark! I have been looking into the Willow and the Elvie, but just can’t bring myself to pay that much out of pocket, although the time saved with these two is very appealing. I have been trying to do my research, but am still overwhelmed with the options and would love your opinion/guidance/advice!
Thank you!
Mallorie
Heather Grace says
Hi Mallorie!
Thank you for the kind words and I am so glad you have found the site helpful! Huge congrats on your second pregnancy!
Exclusively pumping is exhausting and you should feel amazing about making it 9 months!
I have not personally tried the Willow or the Elvie at this time. They are on my list to review but I am with you on the price tag. It’s a little hard to swallow. If I had to pick between those two to try, I would pick the Elvie. I like the idea of the bottle vs the bags. One less thing to have to buy. Plus I believe the Willow bags only hold 4oz vs the 5oz the Elvie bottle holds. Wish I could offer more advice on those 2 options!
As for other pumps that might fit what you need–
If you are looking for something compact and easy to carry around, I would look into the Medela Freestyle, Spectra 9, Ardo Calypso… This article here might help– Click Here- It outlines some of the best pumps for working moms keeping size and portability in mind! I hope this helps!
Mallorie says
Thank you! I have one more question if you don’t mind. One of our close friends who is a L&D nurse would like to gift me 3 months of renting of a hospital grade pump (I know not super portable, but possibly more effective in building a supply/freezer stash) and I cannot thank her enough for her generosity, but I was just wondering what your experience is with hospital grade pumps and how much more effective they are in helping to establish and maintain supply.
Heather Grace says
What an amazing gift! Hospital grade pumps like the Medela Symphony are much more effective. The pump motors are bigger. They have different expression technology. Basically, it’s a much more expensive pump ($1000+ vs $200-$300 for a single user pump) so you get all the bells and whistles when it comes to how the pump operates. I would definitely use one for the first few months!
TampaHeather says
Hi Heather
FTM here and I’m getting close to 30 weeks, so I have no idea what my supply will be like. I plan to be a SAHM for the first 3-6 months (also undecided on that). I want to pump to increase supply so that Dad-to-be can also feed Baby at times.
I have large breasts, but smaller nipples (less than 22mm) and really don’t know how much they’ll change in the coming weeks.
We have awesome insurance, it gives me so many choices, I’m afraid to list them all.
Wish list.
Closed System,
accommodation of pendulous breast with smaller nipple,
portable option,
quiet,
easy access to parts or accessories if needed (worried the standard nipple/flanges won’t suit me)
I already have a stack of Avent bottles or silicone storage systems that I’d prefer to use over one time use plastic bags (I’m trying to be good to the planet)
Thank you so much for creating such a wonderful resource for this topic, which is so confusing
Heather Grace says
Congratulations on your pregnancy!
Trying to prepare for all of this can be quite difficult and overwhelming! One of the biggest things is just what you pointed out– you don’t know exactly how your journey will shake out but it is good to be thinking about all of this. There are many reasons a mom may need to turn to pumping but trying your best to prepare is all you can do.
So, let me try to help you with a few of the things you pointed out/questioned:
1) Pump: A quiet, closed system pump that can be used to pump into Avent bottles? The Spectra S1 is a good choice. The parts are not as widely available in stores but are easy to get online (Amazon has them). The Medela Freestyle or Medela Sonata are great choices too but you would need an adapter to pump into the wide-mouthed Avent bottles. Both are portable, closed system, strong, quiet, and have a wide variety of sizes for the flanges.
2) Accommodation of a pendulous breast with smaller nipple: This should not be an issue with a proper fitting flange and pumping bra. A Lactation Consultant can help fit you if you are not sure of your size.
3) Flange Size: Nowadays, many of the major pump brands offer additional flange sizes for purchase. If you are less than a 22mm, you would be looking at a 21mm in most brands (no 22mm). Most pumps come with a 24mm which is the next size up. You could try the 24mm and if you need to size down, then purchase the 21mm.
I would start by looking at the pumps your insurance has to offer and research the sizing options and other important factors you listed. I would not go purchasing a smaller flange until you try the ones that come with the pump. Sometimes the massage inserts (like the Spectra one) cause the flange to be smaller in size too.
With all that said, Keep in mind that the most important thing you will want to work on once your baby is born is establishing a good latch and supply if you do plan on breastfeeding (vs exclusively pumping). That will be achieved through breastfeeding at the breast for as often and long as baby needs. That is the best thing you can do in those early weeks. If you will be home with your baby for several months, dedicate the first weeks to just breastfeeding, then you can get the pump out.
You don’t want to pump too often especially at first as it will create an oversupply and that comes with a host of issues. Most new moms worry about supply and want to start pumping right away but trust your body and the process. Your body will know what to do and you don’t want to end up with issues if you pump too much.
Again, congratulations and Let me know if I can answer any more questions for you!
Aubrey Madison says
I am looking to get a breast pump from my insurance and I have been lucky enough to have the chance to choose between 11. I don’t even know where to start. I found your amazing blog after hours of research.
I am a stay at home first time mom. I plan to breast feed and pump so that my husband can also help with the baby feedings. We aren’t a family that is on the go too much so I don’t expect to have to travel with my pump.
I am concerned about an open system pump.
My insurance covers Medela pump in Style, Spectra 9 Plus, Spectra S2, Ameda Finesse Double Electric Breast Pump with tote, Ameda Finesse Double Electric Breast Pump, Ardo Calypso Essentials, Tomy Quiet Expression, Lansinoh Signature Pro Double Electric Breast Pump, Lansinoh Smart pump Double Electric, Freemie Standard, and Evenflo Advanced Double Electric.
Any help or recommendations would be helpful.
Heather Grace says
Hi! Congratulations on your baby! You are very lucky to have so many to choose from.
So for your situation:
– Stay at home mom
– Not pumping on the go
– Pumping occasionally
– Want a closed system
I would look at getting the Spectra S2.
It is one of the stronger pumps on your list and offers a lot of features. We don’t always know how our breastfeeding journey will go and if you do end up needing to pump more than you first thought, the Spectra S2 can handle it! The main drawback for the S2 is that it does not have a built-in battery option and needs to be used while plugged in.
My second choice would be a toss-up between the Ameda Finesse and the Ardo Calypso. Both have battery options and are closed system and strong pumps.
I would start by looking at the Spectra S2 and if you aren’t convinced, then consider the Finesse or the Calypso. I hope this helps!
Emily says
Hi! I am looking for a daily pump that will be primarily used in my car. I would prefer to have a battery or car adapter option where I can pump directly into storage bags. My insurance only covers the Ameda Finesse but I am willing to pay out of pocket (small-moderate budget) for something that will better fit my needs as I have read that the Finesse doesn’t do very well on battery power. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Heather Grace says
Hi Emily!
Ameda does make a car adapter for the Finesse! You can view that on their site, here. The Finesse is a great pump and while you can pump on the battery if needed, it also has an AC adapter that allows you to use plugged in.
I do find that pumps like the Finesse that use disposable batteries tend to lose suction strength faster. You can get several hours out of it at full strength, however.
If you prefer to have a pump that has a built-in, rechargeable battery, my favorites are:
Spectra S1
Medela Sonata
Medela Freestyle
You can also buy car adapters for all the pumps above… Personally, I would buy the Ameda adapter and get the pump from your insurance and give it a try! Worse case, shell out the money for a new one later. I hope that helps!
Joyce says
Hi, wanted to ask your advice!! I used Ardo Calypso 3 years ago and it worked well for me. But then I heard about Freemies and how Freemies were so convenient for the working Mom coz it was hands free, I felt so disappointed that Freemie did not have accessories for Ardo but has accessories for Medela and Spectra. Now for my 2nd one, I’m seriously contemplating of getting a Spectra S1 or Medela Pump in Style just so that it can be compatible with a Freemie. On the other hand, I feel torn that I have to fork out big bucks to get a new pump when I already have Ardo. Can you help me out?
Heather Grace says
Hi Joyce!
Gosh, this is a tough one. I love the idea of the Freemies… I have tried them with my Spectra and Medela pumps and they work fine as far as connection to the pumps. BUT they did not work well for me. I was not able to pump as much as I could without them. I don’t have anything to support this theory but I feel like the fact my breasts are so large, they just didn’t fit or stay in place very well. I know many moms who love them and swear by them. But for me, a good old handsfree pumping bra is 1000% easier and I yield way more milk.
I wish I could say it was worth it. I just want to be honest in saying they don’t work for everyone. Have you called your insurance co to see if you qualify for a new pump? Might be worth asking so you don’t have to pay for a new one to try. Hope this helps!
Susie says
Hello everyone! I am a expecting my first child, and so very excited!!! But I am not sure where to start with choosing a pump. I will be using it at work and probably at home so something portable is great, with outlet connectors and battery option. I have large breasts and OMG getting bigger… but I have read from different sites that that doesn’t matter it depends on the nipples. So I’m not sure where to go from here. I know some models are better for lower milk flow but I’m not sure how it will be so I don’t know what to do My insurance covers a few different models of pumps but what’s the best advice you can give me. Anything will help!! Thanks ?
Heather Grace says
Hi Susie!
Congrats on your pregnancy! Choosing a pump for the first time can be very overwhelming. I would first start with looking at the pumps your insurance covers. If you want to list them here, we can go over the best from that list.
Breast size does not matter, that’s true. It is the size of your nipple. Most pumps come with a few flanges to try so you can find your size. A Lactation Consultant is also able to fit you if you need additional help.
As for the best portable, powerful pumps? My top recommendations are:
1) Spectra S1
2) Medela Sonata
3) Medela Freestyle
4) Ameda Finesse
You can see all these pumps and a few more on this article about the best portable pumps for working moms (click here!).
Let me know if I can answer any questions!
Sarah says
Hi I’m not sure which pump to get but here are some of the things I’m looking for:
-good for large breasts (36H)
-occasional pumping, possibly exclusively later
– strongest closed system (worried about Mold and bacteria in open systems)
– I have good to over production so I want comfort, something that feels gentle like baby and won’t give me sore nipples but still effective
– double electric
– no budget
– stationary is ok but portable is better just in case
Please help me decide what is the best option! I want the best but I don’t like that medela is an open system and I saw Ameda at a baby show and hear that it’s more comfortable but I also read that suction is poor. What’s your advice? Thanks for your help!
Heather Grace says
Hi Sarah!
So glad you are here. I would love to help you choose!
So going down your list you really would be best off going with either the Ameda Finesse or the Spectra S2.
Reasons they fit what you are looking for:
1) strong pumps- good for exclusive pumping
2) feature max comfort while pumping
3) closed system
4) easy to clean
5) lightweight.
6) Your breast size doesn’t actually matter when it comes to pumping. It is the size and shape of your nipples. Both the Finesse and the S2 comes with several breastshields for you to try so that you get the best fit.
Some key differences between the Spectra S2 and the Ameda Finesse:
1) Ameda Finesse has the option to run off disposable batteries, S2 is not portable (unless you get an aftermarket battery pack)
2) Ameda Finesse is smaller and lighter than the S2
3) I personally find the S2 to be the stronger pump (it yields me more milk than the Finesse)
4) Spectar S2 is digital and has the ability to record your preferred pump pattern, etc and the Finesse is controlled with manual dials
5) Spectra S2 is typically slightly cheaper than the Finesse (unless one is on sale)
I love both of these pumps. I prefer pumping with the S2 as far as experience in both the digital controls for ease and the suction strength (more milk) but prefer the Finesse if I need to be on the go. So choosing between the two will depend on where you need to pump and how often you need to take it on the go.
Just a note: Spectra does make a portable version of the S2 called the Spectra S1. The S1 has a built-in rechargeable battery but is more expensive than the S2 (and the Finesse). You mentioned budget as an important line item so the S2 is the cheaper option but I wanted you to know there was a version with a battery pack.
I hope this information helps narrow it down for you! Let me know if you have any other questions!
Sarah says
Thank you so much for your feedback. Actually I meant that budget was not an issue for me so whatever you think is the best quality. I have been leaning toward the spectra S1 or the Ameda but sometimes it’s hard to decide with all the mixed reviews online.
On a side note: I read somewhere that the medela freestyle was actually closed but then I always see that medela pumps are open system. Is the freestyle in fact open or closed system?
Heather Grace says
I see.
Well, if I had to choose between the two, I would pick the S1. I think the fact it has a built-in rechargeable battery puts it over the edge for me.
And yes, the Medela Freestyle is a closed system. Quite a few of their pumps are (Symphony, Sonata, Freestyle, etc). I hope this helps!
Ans says
I will need a pump for work that I can leave there. The designated space for pumping is far away from my office so I’d like to pump at my desk with a curtain around my cubicle for my own convenience. What is a powerful pump that my insurance might cover that is not as loud as Medela Pump in Style or Spectra 2? Or do you have other advice on how to minimize noise.
Heather Grace says
The Ardo Calypso is one of the quietest pumps on the market and still is a very strong pump. I would definitely recommend checking it out. Your insurance you give you an allowance to spend toward a pump or they might have a specific pump they cover. I used this company to call and work with my insurance with my last baby since I wanted an upgrade from the pump they offered. Worth having them do the work since its a free service!
As for tips to keep the noise level down- I found leaving my pump inside my pump bag helped some. But it depends on the pump since you don’t want it to overheat. I used to play a little music too when I wasn’t using the nursing room… though my office environment allowed for that. But hey, at the end of the day, your coworkers will get used to it haha! I hope this helps!
Lindsay says
I am almost due with my 4th child. I have used a medal and Spectra S2. I’m considering the Calypso or the S1 this time. What do you suggest? I am an occasional pumper. I pump more often at first to boost my supply as I have never seemed to have much extra. Out of the two I tried, I’m not really sure which one worked better. I am really struggling to decide which one to go with. I know the S1 works, but I had problems with leaking bottles last time. The calypso doesn’t even have bottles. Most of the time, my kids have stuck with tomee tippee bottles anyway so I don’t know if that matters.
Heather Grace says
Hi Lindsay!
So let me preface this by saying that I love both the S1 and the Calypso. I think both will work great but to help you narrow it down, here are a few thoughts to consider:
The S1 and the S2 (which you mentioned you have used) are actually the same exact pump. The only difference is the S1 has a built-in rechargeable battery. That might be something to consider about the S1 since if you didn’t care much for the S2, then you will be disappointed in the S1. (Though I adore the S1- it is one of my favorite pumps).
The Calypso does lose some suction strength when running off of its battery. You mentioned only being an occasional pumper so this may not matter. Also, it is way more compact than the S1 so it will be easier to take on the go if you need to.
If you need the stronger suction and comfort, then I recommend the S1. If you want something smaller that still will give you good output and is whisper quiet, the Calypso is my choice. Hope this helps!
Desiree says
Hello!
I have a question as to which pump I should get. I’m pregnant with my second and have a moderate to no budget. I do have insurance and will be using that.
With my first, he had latch issues due to a tongue and lip tie and many other issues so, needless to say I had a super low supply and only ever pumped maybe 2 oz. total a day. I had the Ameda purely yours and see now why I needed something better. I am a SAHM, would like to breastfeed but understand I need a pump to build supply with a stronger suction. Which would you recommend? Have you ever heard of the Mybabybuddha and if so what do you think of it? Thank you!
Heather Grace says
HI Desiree,
It definitely sounds like you could have benefited from a stronger pump than the Ameda Purely Yours. A few pumps I would recommend you check out are:
Spectra S1 – This is an amazingly strong pump and perfect for moms who suffer from low milk supply. (some insurances will cover the S1 or the Spectra S2)
Medela Sonata – Features Medela’s hospital grade technology and connect to the MyMedela App to track ounces pumped. Love this pump. (you may see about a credit for an upgrade for the Sonata. Typically Medela’s insurance issued pump is the Pump in Style but you can upgrade in some cases)
Ameda Finesse – This is a good pump (though I prefer the Spectra and Sonata) and often offered through insurance. One of the more comfortable pumps I have ever used and has good suction.
Any one of these would be an amazing choice for a mom with low milk supply. Also, check out my review on Aeroflow Breastpumps. They can handle your insurance order for your pump FREE of charge. The great thing is that their staff can walk you through each pump your insurance offers and help you with an upgrade if you need one. I have used their service twice now and it makes things much easier.
As for the My Baby Buddha. I have not personally tried this pump though I am aware of it. I love how small and compact it is. It does have a max mmHg of 320 per their website which is impressive for such a small pump. One thing about pumps that run off a battery that I like to test thoroughly is how well they perform when the battery starts to drain. There are some pumps that loose suction very fast even with 75%+ of battery life left. Without having tried this pump, I can’t speak to the pump strength or if it can sustain a moms milk supply. I wish I could give you more feedback on that one. It is on my list to review, however!
I hope this helps! Huge congrats on your pregnancy!
Desiree says
Thank you so much for your reply! The Spectras definitely seem to be helping lots of mamas. The Medela Sonata is definitely on my lost of one to see if I can get upgraded to. I’ll check out Aeroflow for these. Thank you so much again for taking the time to reply!
Heather Grace says
No problem! Let me know if I can help answer any more questions!
dAnielle says
HI Heather
I am a first time mom who is Eping due to latch issues (despite working with 4 LCs 🙁 )
I have a Medela PIS and am not in love with it. It takes me 40mins to pump and feels like I still have some in there. I’ve experimented with different size flanges and suction settings with no avail.
I also suffer from low supply, my baby is 8weeks and I only make about 13oz a day which is half of what she needs.
I recently switched insurance and can get another pump. My options are Medela, Ardo Calypso, Ameda and I haven’t looked into the spectra but that may be covered.
What is your suggestion? My top priority is a more efficient milk extraction and the PIS isn’t working well for me. I would also love it to be portable if possible so I’m not feeling so tied down but again my top priority is efficiency
Thank you
Danielle
Heather Grace says
First of all, huge congrats on your new baby!
I know those first few weeks can be a huge struggle! If you haven’t already, sign up for my free ebook on how to increase your milk supply. You can use those techniques as an exclusive pumper as well. It may give you some additional info on try to pump more.
Now, about the pump:
The Medela PISA, Ardo Calypso, and Ameda are all pretty similar pumps strength wise. If you are struggling with the PISA, you might require something stronger. I would suggest asking about the Spectra S1 and see if that is covered. I would also inquire about renting a hospital grade pump like the Medela Symphony. Often times your insurance will cover the rental of one especially if you have visited lactation as often as you mentioned.
It would be well worth going with a Hospital strength pump at this point. Inquire about those two options. If they aren’t covered, it might be worth spending the money for a new Spectra S1 (or S2 which is cheaper but you lose the portability).
Let me know if I can answer any other questions once you see if your insurance has other options!
Kristen Wright says
My son was born 2 months premature, so I will be exclusively pumping until he is able to suckle. My insurance covers the Ameda Fineses, Ardo Calypso, Medela pump in style, Spectra s2. I can upgrade and pay for the Spectra s1.
So far my milk supply is good, but that is with using the hospital pump Ameda. Which pump should I get?
Heather Grace says
Hi Kristen!
Congratulations on the birth of your baby! I wish you a speedy NICU stay!
You have some great pumps to choose from. With a healthy supply, you will likely be fine with any that you listed. My favorite pumps on your list are the Spectra S1 and S2. The only difference between the two is that the S1 has a built-in rechargeable battery. If you are ok with having to pump using a power outlet, then the S2 will be great.
The Ardo Calypso is also a great pump and is super quiet. If you need to pump in an office setting, the Ardo is great.
The Finesse is small, lightweight and features technology from Ameda’s hospital grade pump the Ameda Platinum. It is extremely comfortable to use and if you are already using the hospital grade pump, then you will likely be right at home with the Finesse. It’s a very good pump.
The Medela Pump in Style is a strong pump but to me, it doesn’t have all the technology and bells and whistles as some of your other choices. It’s often a pretty stripped down version for insurance as well (unless they state otherwise) and you don’t get a ton of accessories.
So if I had to choose, I would go with the Spectra S1 or S2. The Finesse might be a close second (if you already have attachments, that might sway me even more toward the Finesse), followed by the Ardo Calypso and then the Medela Pump in Style.
I hope this helps! Let me know if I can answer any more questions about the pumps for you!
Deanna says
Hi there! I am a FTM trying to navigate the world of breastfeeding. I am due in July, following which I will take a 6 month maternity leave. Then, I will return to work full time and will need a pump that is efficient and portable. My insurance covers the Ameda Finesse in full, or I can chose a pump of my preference, and be reimbursed up to $200. I am more than willing to spend more for a better pump that suits my needs. I am also interested in using the Kiinde Twist system with my pump, or possibly Lifefactory glass bottles. Any pump that is a must have, and worth the splurge beyond the Ameda Finesse? I appreciate your help!
Heather Grace says
Hi Deanna!
Congratulation on your upcoming arrival! The Ameda Finesse is a great pump in its own right. It is lightweight and very portable. It is a strong enough pump to maintain a healthy supply. You would likely do great with it.
If you were looking for a stronger pump with more features (digital controls, ability to program your pump settings, etc), then an upgrade would definitely be a pump like the Spectra S1. It is portable with a rechargeable battery but is bigger than the Finesse. It retails for close to that $200 mark too so you may be able to get it fully covered.
Now, if you wanted it all (portability, features, strong pump) a splurge would be the Medela Freestyle. By far one of my favorites! It will literally fit in your purse and has it all. This pump was made for a working mom but is more than $200 so you would be out of pocket for it.
I think it comes down to budget (Freestyle being the most expensive), how portable you need the pump (where you will be pumping and if you need to carry it around), and finally, how strong you need the pump. Since this is your first, you have not experienced any issues as of yet with low milk supply but the Spectra is an amazing pump for moms who struggle to pump enough because of how strong it is, yet comfortable to use.
All three of these are compatible with the Kiinde System which is a great choice!
You have some great options but I would look at those three more and see if you can narrow it down to fit your situation. I hope this helps!
Brianna says
Hello,
I am a FTM and having trouble deciding between the pumps that are covered by my insurance at 100%.
I will be pumping on the go the majority of the time. My work is 90% travel so I will be pumping from my company car most of the time. Sometimes the cities that I am in don’t have pumping friendly locations. I’m planning on plugging the pump into my power inverter so battery operated is not necessarily a must have.
The pump options that my insurance covers are:
Madela pump in style
Spectra S2
Evenflo Deluxe
Freemie hands free Deluxe
Lansinoh smartpump
Ameda Finesse
Please let me know what you suggest. Thank you!
Heather Grace says
Hi Brianna!
Of the pumps you listed, my favorites are the Medela Pump in Style, Spectra S2, and Ameda Finesse. I personally have not had as much luck with the other listed in term of milk yield. I pull down more milk with the other 3.
Now with that said, between the 3 I prefer, the Medela Pump in Style and Ameda Finesse both run off disposable batteries which might come in very handy in your situation just in case you need it. The Spectra S2 does not have any type of battery. It can only be used plugged in. I have found an external power cell that works with the S2 but you need to purchase that and rechargeable batteries separately.
In terms of suction, the Spectra S2 is the stronger pump followed by the Pump in Style and then the Finesse. Both the S2 and the Finesse are a little more comfortable to use physically (if nipple pain while pumping is a concern). Though pumping should never hurt, the S2 and Finesse feel more like a baby would nurse vs the Pump in Style which is more like a tug.
If you absolutely do not care if the pump can run off a battery, I would go with the Spectra S2. It is the stronger pump and will yield you more milk. If you want a more compact pump, then the Finesse is by far the smallest and lightest. The Pump in Style typically comes built into a pump bag already (a tote or backpack) so that makes it convenient to carry around.
The S2 is my pick, overall. Then between the Pump in Style and Finesse, I would say it comes down to which is easier. I like the backpack Pump in Style for your situation and that might win me over.
Also, something else to consider to make your life easier on the go is using a pump and store system like the Kiinde Twist. It is compatible with all three of those pumps. So you can pump directly into the storage bags and store them (even freeze), then thaw and give to baby directly from the bag! It is amazing and may help save you time and having to lug milk collection bottles or pour milk from bottle to bag while out and about. Anyway, let me know if you have any other questions I can answer for you! I hope this helps! Thank you for your question!
Bethany says
I’m pregnant with my second baby and the first time around I had a very low milk supply. Was using the Medela Pump in Style last time and would get 1oz total after 45 minutes. I plan on exclusively pumping this time around and want to make sure I get a quality breast pump. I work from home so I don’t need portability necessarily. My insurance plan will cover spectra S2, Medela Pump in style, Ameda Finesse, and ARDO Calypso at 100%. Then premium pumps are listed for a copay less than $50 for most of them. (Spectra S1, Medela sonata, Medela freestyle, Medela Pump in style and advanced, and ARDO Calypso-to-go), I’m willing to spend extra money if need be because I’ll be using it a lot! Thanks in advance!
Heather Grace says
Hi Bethany,
Gosh, I wish I had your insurance! They have so many amazing options! Okay, so this is a super easy one for me… The Medela Sonata. Hands-down.
I have not finished writing my full review of this pump yet so it is not published but I am seriously in love with it. (I will update this comment for anyone reading this in the future with the link to the full review once it is published). This is by far the best pump on your list. Medela spent years designing this pump. It is modeled after their hospital grade monster, the Symphony. But compacted into an amazing personal-use pump. It comes with amazing technology, is whisper quiet (I had to put my ear to it to hear it), links to their amazing app to track your pumping sessions and more, and comes with amazing accessories. If you can get this pump for a mere $50, you should jump at the chance! Especially since you mentioned that you had difficulty pumping in the past, the Sonata is hospital grade strength (though Medela will not use that term – they save those for their actual hospital pumps). I can’t say enough great things about this pump. That would def be my pick!!
Becca R says
I am a first time mommy, who is really confused about pumps. I will be on maternity leave for 6 weeks, then back to work as a teacher. I will hopefully pump everyday, and while at work. My insurance covers both the Medela, and the Spectra S1/2, so that is not a problem. I obviously have never had to breastfeed before, so I don’t have preferences, because I don’t know what I need. Any help would be greatly appreciated!!!
Heather Grace says
Hi Becca,
I think you have come to the right place! You will find a ton of information here on The Pumping Mommy about working and pumping.
So let’s start with the pump. The Medela pump offered by insurance companies is a stripped down version of the Medela Pump in Style (some offer accessories like a tote bag and cooler and extra parts, some don’t). The Pump in Style is a really good pump. I used it for 2 years while pumping for my first baby and working 60+ hours a week. Never had an issue.
Now, the Spectra S1 and S2 are the same pump. The difference? The S1 has a rechargeable battery making it portable. The S2 must be used while plugged in.
So really, I would be choosing between the Spectra S1 and the Medela pump. Both are great pumps. Both are portable. I wrote an article comparing these two pumps, you can read all the differences and similarities in that article, here. In the end, I prefer the Spectra S1. You really have some good pumps to choose from, lucky you!
Since you are returning to work very early (sorry you only get 6 weeks!), establishing good breastfeeding habits for your baby like a good latch, good supply, ect will be important early on. Take full advantage of the Lactation Consultant in the hospital (assuming you haven’t had your baby yet)! Don’t assume one will come to you, request to see one! You can bring your pump to the hospital (if you have it by then) and they can show you how to operate it. They usually have follow-up clinics so if you are having any trouble while at home, going back to the clinic is the best thing you can do. If you have already had your baby, going back and seeing an LC with your pump might be a good idea. They can also fit the breastshield to make sure it is the right size.
Your milk supply will be all over the place after birth once your milk comes in. It takes several weeks (ideally 12 weeks) to establish a good supply and habits so be diligent with putting your baby to the breast as often as they want and with your pumping while away from your baby which I am sure is easier said than done especially being a teacher. You may need to add pump sessions at home to keep up with your baby if you do not get enough time at work.
Here are some good pages to read to get you started:
1 – Working and Pumping Home Page
2 – Tips for Pumping at Work
3 – Pumping Basics
4 – How to build a Freezer Stash
5 – Sample Pumping Schedule
I hope this helps! Also, if you haven’t already, sign up to get my free eBook about increasing your milk supply. There are 10 pages of helpful info on how supply and demand works and the basics of breastfeeding. I am offering it for free right now. I hope this helps you!! Let me know if you have any questions! Take care and congrats on your baby!
Shalah says
HELP!! I’m stuck between getting a Medela PISA or a Spectra S1. My insurance covers both so that isn’t a problem. I loved my Medela PISA with my first baby. I ended up exclusively pumping since I went back to school early after he was born, I never had a problem with the suction being to hard or getting milk in my tubing. However, I’ve been researching the S1 and saw that many prefer it over the PISA. I love what I’ve read about both and am stuck on which to get.
Heather Grace says
Hi! So, you are getting to choose between two very good pumps. The Spectra is a slightly stronger pump, it is closed system, and I find it is overall a more comfortable pump to use. But the Medela will have parts that are easier to get a hold of (Spectra is online) and is a great pump, as you know. If it were me, I would look at a few things:
1) do you have pump parts from your first baby left over? This will cut down on cost since you will already have extra sets vs having to buy some for the Spectra.
2) How do you feel about having to shop online for the Spectra Parts?
They are both great pumps and you really can’t go wrong here so I think you just need to look at some of those small details. If you have a ton of parts for the Medela PISA, I would probably stay with that. If you are starting over, you might want to consider trying out the Spectra S1. Great, great pump and one of my favorites! I put the Medela PISA head to head with the Spectra S1 in this article, so jump over and give it a read to see all the differences. I hope this helps!
Shannon says
Hi Shalah, I’m guessing you’ve already decided, but just in case you haven’t, wanted to let you know about the Maymom adapter. It lets you use the S1/S2 with Medela personalfit connectors (or all-in-ones with flanges) and Medela bottles, which are a lot nicer than Spectra bottles. You can then connect Pumpin Pals to the personalfit connectors (instead of the Medela flanges), which I’d recommend.
Just wanted to let you know about this, as it’s an easy way to use Medela parts, while having the closed system of the S1, which is rated for more hours than the PISA.
Heather Grace says
Thank you for pointing that out, Shannon. Yes, the Spectra pumps are able to be used with the Medela attachments if you have the adapters. Those are not official parts by Spectra. I have the correct adapters listed on the Spectra parts page for anyone who is interested- You can find them under “Additional Accessories.” There are two different adapters- one for the Medela breast shields to connect to the Spectra tubing and one for the Medela collection bottles to attach to the Spectra breast shields. So you have the option to use the entire Medela collection kit (bottle, breast shields) or just the collection bottles. Hope that helps!
Katie says
Hi there,
3rd time mom who has used the Medela Pump in Style for babies 1 and 2. I’m looking for a new pump this time and my insurance covers several including the pump in style and Ameda Finesse, Freemie Freedom and a few others. I’ll return to work about 5 months after this baby is born and will pump regularly there, but also 1-2 times/day while on leave. What would you recommend?
Heather Grace says
Hi Katie,
Congratulations on your third baby! Fellow mom-of-three here and it is a crazy mix of chaos and bliss!
Of the three pumps you listed, the Pump in Style is still my favorite. I have had the most success with it vs the other two. The Ameda Finesse is a great pump and I really like it. I found I pumped more with my Pump in Style, however. It’s not a significant difference but it is a difference. If you are sensitive to pumping (the Pump in Style can be rough), the Ameda Finesse is much more comfortable in my opinion. Both pumps will get the job done but like I said, I typically pump more with my Pump in Style and when you are trying to maintain a supply while working, those extra ounces count for a lot.
You can read my full review of the Pump in Style, here.
And the Ameda Finesse, here.
I have not written a full review n the Freemie Freedom, but I never had luck with the Freemie pumps. They just didn’t work for me. I know plenty of moms who love them but they are not pumps I typically recommend based on my experience.
I hope this helps!! Let me know if you have any other questions!
Suselis says
Hi there! I am not sure which pump is the best for me and I could really use your advice/expertise. With my 2 sons I never could pump/breastfeed past 3 months, I had very little milk supply and it just vanished at the 3month mark or was next to mom exsistent. I have always had the medela pump in style provided through insurance and I have never liked it so I am wanting to get something different this time. To answer your questions…
How often will you be pumping? – daily
Where will you be pumping? Do you need a portable pump? – always at home or in a home
Are you suffering from low milk supply or need to pump exclusively? I have a low milk supply and have a very hard time breastfeeding because of how large my breast are so I pump more often than breastfeed
What is your budget? We are covered through insurance so I should be able to get any electric breastpump with the exception of the medela type hospital pumps.
Heather Grace says
Hi, Suselis! The Medela Pump in Style is a great pump. If you had some supply issues using even that pump, I would suggest you get a Hospital Grade pump this go around. You can rent one (Medela Symphony for example) or you buy one. My personal favorite (and the most affordable option) is the Spectra pumps. The Spectra S2 would work for you since you don’t seem to need to built in battery option. The S2 only works off an AC adapter. You can read about the Spectra S2, here.
Your insurance may not offer the Spectra pumps as an option, however, since they are not widely used in the States. Another option would be to see if your insurance company will cover the cost of renting a Hospital Grade pump. Some do. You did mention the hospital types is an exception so I am not sure if that means they won’t cover a rental cost either. It sounds like you could use the extra power of hospital grade.
As for helping your supply, there many things you can do. I am not sure of your situation but if you have to leave your baby within the first few months, then pumping would be inevitable. But if you have the ability to be home with your baby, I recommend that you focus the first few months on only breastfeeding. Establish a good latch and a good supply before trying to pump. This article may help you with some ideas for boosting your supply if needed: Not Pumping Enough Breast milk
A Lactation Consultant early on is a must. I am sure since you have been through this before, you have tried a lot of things. Hang in there! Not everyone’s breastfeeding journey is the same. I wish you the best!
Samantha says
Hi, I am debating between getting the Spectra S1 and the Medela Freestyle. I will be returning to work after the baby is born. So, I will be pumping multiple times per day. With my DD, I used the PISA. It was overall an ok pump, however, I did have issues producing at the pump. So, I am wanting to find something a little better for people with production issues. Thank you so much for the help!
Heather Grace says
Hi, Samantha! Both the Spectra S1 and the Freestyle are both great pumps. You will find pros and cons with both. The main difference will be the size. The Freestyle is much smaller and therefore slightly more portable. Though the S1 isn’t massive and I carried it around just fine but the Freestyle could literally be popped into your purse which I loved.
The pump strength is going to be very similar. I do feel the S1 runs better and longer without being plugged into the wall if you will be away from a power source when you pump. Overall, you would have good success pumping the max amount of milk with either. One thing to consider is that the S1 is more comfortable to use than the Freestyle. It is very gentle. That can make a difference in output for some moms. So if you struggle with pumping, the S1 might be something to consider.
I think you have narrowed it down to two great pumps. If you haven’t already read them, here are my full reviews for both pumps so you can see the specs. Click here for the S1 review. Click here for the Freestyle review.
If you have any specific questions about either pump, please let me know. Congrats on your baby and I hope you come back and let me know which you chose!
TampaHeather says
Thank you Heather, you’re so amazing. I truly appreciate the support and your amazing wealth of knowledge on top of the clear way you write. Its incredibly helpful and I’m most grateful
Heather Grace says
Thank you very much for your sweet comment! I am so glad you found this information useful!
netp says
Hi there, I find the medela swing one is really effective — I just can’t get on with the manual ones, they seem to take so long and the effectiveness of the electric sort is so much quicker, although the feeling of being a bit like a milking cow is a bit weird. I actually had a double one at one point, but I ended up creating too much milk – my supply went way up and it was coming out too fast when I was doing it naturally 🙁
Heather Grace says
Over pumping will definitely create an over supply. You really only need to pump to replace feedings. Anything beyond that can cause an over supply. If you need to increase your supply or need to build a freezer stash, for example, then pumping while nursing can be a great benefit!
I never loved manual pumps either. Great in emergency situations but not my go to. Finding what pump works for you and will best fit your siutation is key!
Heather Grace says
Great, Tammy! I am so glad you found this helpful! If you need any suggestions, let me know!